Strengths Campus

fostering a community of people interested in exploring strengths

Male and Female Leadership Characteristics?

I'm facilitating part of a leadership program right now- 25 up and coming women leaders. Terrific group of women. A lot of talent in the room. On one of the first days of their year-long course, they studied male vs female leadership characteristics. Every time I think about it, something in me squirms. I don't even know really what I think, I just know that when we say women leaders are more xyz and men leaders are more abc: I sorta scrunch up my face. Perhaps it's because I've worked with many many leaders, male and female, and many of the men were consultative, sensitive, empathetic and many of the women were assertive, hard-nosed and decisive. Even as I write out those words my skin kinda contracts- like I'm saying bad words. Am I the only one who feels like something is wrong with calling any characteristics male or female? I hate the expression "He's in touch with his feminine side." No, he's just learned that being kind and understanding is a HUMAN thing and highly valued.
Maybe it's my upbringing: my Dad raised us and my Mom was a tremendous influence as a successful woman manager and leader. So, I'm used to people just doing what they do well (and what needs to be done) no matter their gender. But, I realize that my perspective may not be shared by that many. Obviously, if a whole day of our leadership program's curriculum was spent extolling the virtues of a female leader, some people must believe that there's a difference. Do you? Do you still see a marked difference in the way that women lead vs men? Can you give some specific examples? And what about this concept that women leaders are actually more competitive with their female counterparts than their male colleagues? Have you heard that as well? See, I've never experienced it personally so I'm curious if it's a made up "cat-fight" (UGH!) stereotype. I'm hoping so. I sorta thought we were beyond all of this. I almost don't want to get into the debate in case I'm wrong!

In your organization, are there more women or men leaders? Even? Do you think it's your industry? I worked in real estate forever, and, yes, the entire senior team save me, the HR person, were men. I know that's not surprising- so perhaps there are roles that are still more commonly held by women, but once in the role- do they really have such clearly demarcated styles?

Someone please chime in and give me your impression/opinion.

I'm of the humble opinion, that people are excellent as managers and leaders because they understand their strengths and now how to leverage them to serve in the best way they can- whether they pee standing up or not. (I hope I can say that.)(See, that's the Canadian in me- worried about offending. Sorry if I did. (More Canadian: apologizing for everything)). (Brings up a good point though: more difference between leaders culturally than based on gender?)(Overdoing the parentheses.)

Tell me your opinion!

 

 

Views: 469

Comment

You need to be a member of Strengths Campus to add comments!

Join Strengths Campus

Comment by Tracy Jean Hutton on March 16, 2011 at 9:24pm
Obfuscates is a fine fine word. Thanks for adding to the idea, I'm with you. I think this is what prevents people from being true to their nature. Men who prefer a "softer" approach worry that they won't be viewed with the same respect as a more direct counterpart - because they're not being, what, manly? Pshaw. What works is what's important.
Comment by Darren Raymond on March 14, 2011 at 11:28am
Finally, someone who uses more parentheses than I do! (or at least as many). I'm with you, Tracy. I feel like we have some weird need to catalogue and categorize everything into neat little gender-based clusters even though people's traits and talents are individual, not according to class. I'll admit that I do from time to time feel like there's a difference in male and female communication styles, but part of me feels like that's bunk, too. Yes, some women communicate this way, and some men communicate that way. But I hardly think it's universal. I think (warning: genius insight ahead) there are innate differences between men and women that affect everything we do in subtle ways, but whenever we try to chunk it out into "sensitive" means female and "assertive" means male, it just seems ridiculous. We can call any trait male or female if we want, but when it comes to personality, it seems like it obfuscates more than it clarifies.

© 2012   Created by TMBC.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service